Casey Key Guide

Located on the shimmering Gulf Coast, Casey Key is a pristine paradise that epitomizes luxury living. Overlooking the deep azure waters, the real estate offerings here are nothing short of spectacular, inviting discerning homebuyers to a life of unparalleled opulence. There are only about 400 homes that rest on the barrier island of Casey Key. If you enjoy the outdoors, you will definitely appreciate the fishing, and beach recreational activities.

And, if you haven't already, be sure to register for a free account so that you can receive email alerts whenever new Casey Key Real Estate listings come on the market.

What you need to know about Casey Key Florida

Casey Key is a beautiful lush barrier island 15 miles south of Sarasota of the typical track and sort of a hidden secret without traffic lights. Casey Key extends from Siesta Key on the north to the Island of Venice toward the south. About 8 miles long and 300 yards wide. Most of the island is a conservation district established by the Florida Legislature.

Real Estate is in high demand due to its location. Average prices are around $2.5 Million with square foot prices just around $1,000 with luxuriant waterfront estates in the upper end of the range.

Celebrities such as Stephen King is known to have a winter home on Casey Key. Rosie O'Donnell had a property on the island until 2015. Sure, who would not be attracted to the islands secluded beaches and the nearby amenities. It's a perfect place to soak up the sun and scenery.

Located in the southern part of Sarasota County, Casey Key is a narrow barrier island that boasts a marine conservation area, providing a serene and natural environment that's ideal for a quiet, relaxing vacation. With an array of activities, from beaches to wildlife watching, and a rich history, it offers something for everyone.

1. Beaches: Casey Key is home to several miles of pristine beaches.

Nokomis Beach: Located between Lyons Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. Features sand and seashells, sheltered by palm trees and tropical shrubs. Amenities: boat-launching ramp, boardwalk, picnic area, snack bar, and free car parking. Special Attraction: The town's drum circle meets a couple of evenings each week. North Jetty Park Beach: Located at the island's southernmost tip with fine, white sand. Renowned as one of the best spots for surfing on Florida's west coast. Lifeguards are on duty during peak hours.

2. Wildlife Watching: The island is a haven for nature enthusiasts. Bird-Watching: The mangroves and wild sea oats provide habitats for numerous native bird species. Marine Life: Dolphins often swim close to the shore, and visitors can spot endangered manatees and other aquatic wildlife. Sea turtles also frequent the island. Nature Explorations: Enjoy the island's flora and fauna via nature walks or rent a bicycle.

3. Boating: The Intracoastal Waterway runs along Casey Key, and the west coast faces the Gulf of Mexico, offering boating opportunities. Cool Breeze Boat & Jet Ski Rentals: Based at the Gulf Harbor Marina, they provide full or half-day charters for boating. They offer deck boats, pontoon boats, and personal watercraft for rent. Kayaking is also available, allowing visitors to explore Venice Inlet and the coastal mangroves.

4. Fishing: North Jetty Beach is favored for shore fishing. Deep-sea fishing charters are available from the marina. North Jetty Fish Camp provides fishing gear and bait. Casey Key Fish House: A local eatery that serves locally caught seafood.

5. Historical Insights: Notable resident: Author Stephen King has a winter home in Casey Key. The population of the Nokomis/Casey Key area was 3,334 during the 2000 census. U.S. Army Captain John Charles Casey was sent to the island around 1849 to survey it and interacted closely with the Seminole Indians. Historical Bridges: The Blackburn Point Road Bridge, built in 1926, is one of the few swing bridges still in operation in the U.S. and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

6. Casey Key Today: The northern part of the island, beyond the Albee Road Bridge, is a conservation district established in the early 1970s. Real estate on Casey Key is now valued in the millions, with some properties having their own private beaches. This guide offers a snapshot of what Casey Key has to offer. Whether you're an avid nature lover, a beachgoer, or a history enthusiast, Casey Key promises a fulfilling experience.

Casey Key • Sarasota • FL • Real Estate
Looking to sell or buy a home on Casey Key, Sarasota? Call HomeMaxi, your Casey Key real estate team at (941) 800-1680. We are your Casey Key REALTORS® and experts on the Southwest Florida housing market.

Contact us to Learn More About Casey Key

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.